East Islip · Since 2010
Blue Line
Deli & Bagels
Breakfast Specials · Lunch Heroes · Fresh Bagels
Since
2,010
In The Game
50 +
Menu Items
10,000 +
Happy Customers
Open
7
Days A Week
Our Story
The Best Food
In Town.
"Come on in and try out the best food in town! We only use the finest ingredients — we promise you'll keep coming back! If you're a hockey fan, you really need to come on in and check out our hockey-themed deli."
🏒
Hockey-Themed
A deli with arena energy — jerseys, sticks, and serious sandwiches.
🥯
Fresh Bagels Daily
Baked every morning. Thirteen varieties. No exceptions.
🥪
Finest Ingredients
Only the good stuff — sourced local, prepped fresh.
15+
Years Strong
In The Wild
Fresh From The Kitchen
A look at what's coming out the window today.
French Toast 
Pancakes 
Cheeseburger Deluxe 
Calamari 
Chicken Fingers 
Specialty Plate 
Deli Counter 
Inside 
Specials 
Hot & Ready 
Breakfast 
Daily Special 
Breakfast Wrap 
Bagel Sandwich 
Fresh & Hot 
Blue Line Special 
Hot Sandwich 
Omelette 
Lunch Special 
Our Shop Power Play Reviews
From The Crease
What the regulars are saying about their go-to deli.
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
"The Hat Trick sandwich is an absolute power play. Best deli on Long Island."
MR
Mike R.
East Islip
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
"Came for the bagels, stayed for the hockey vibe. Five stars, no penalty shot needed."
SK
Sarah K.
Bay Shore
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
"The Hungry Man is exactly what it sounds like. Legendary breakfast spot."
TD
Tom D.
Islip
Drop The Puck
Get In Touch
Catering, big orders, or just questions — we're here for it.
Address
217 Carlton Ave.
East Islip, NY 11730
Hours
Monday — Sunday
6 AM — 2 PM · Open 7 Days
Send A Message
We'll get back to you fast